GM just crushed its earnings report, so why are investors fleeing?

General Motors (GM) recently released its fourth-quarter earnings report that exceeded analyst predictions, yet the company’s stock fell by more than 8% following the announcement, pushed by investor fears over a host of domestic and international challenges facing the automaker.

The selloff appears to be driven by a handful of factors, including fear around its profitability in China, continued growth of its EV sector, and, most of all, incoming tariffs on goods from Mexico and Canada, where GM produces more than a third of the vehicles it sales in the U.S.

Related: The most and least expensive states to own a car in 2025

GM’s electric vehicle gamble

Despite GM’s impressive financials, concerns about its future growth persist. The company’s push into electric vehicles (EVs), which is vital to its long-term strategy, continues to face challenges. GM’s electric vehicle business made progress toward profitability in 2024, with the company producing 189,000 EVs in North America. However, this fell short of its target of 200,000 vehicles. GM has said that it aims to produce 300,000 EVs in 2025.

2024 Chevrolet Equinox EV

Chevy

The company’s ambitious EV projections are complicated by an unpredictable market for electric cars, which saw much slower growth in 2024 compared to previous years. Although GM’s EV sales in the U.S. have more than doubled since Q1 of 2024, it still possesses just a fraction—about 12%—of the total market, with some analysts questioning whether the company can meet its 2025 EV targets, given the competition from rivals like Tesla and Ford.

Moreover, regulatory uncertainties—particularly with the Biden administration’s tax incentives for EVs—create further risks. If the Trump administration succeeds in rolling back these tax credits, GM’s EV sales could stall, hurting its profitability and growth trajectory.

Related: 2024 Toyota Grand Highlander Hybrid Max review: A proverbial homerun

Tariff threats and regulatory overhang

One of the most significant factors dragging down GM’s stock is the looming threat of tariffs on imports from Canada and Mexico. The Trump administration has proposed a 25% tariff on goods imported from these two countries, where GM has substantial manufacturing operations. In 2024, GM produced nearly 900,000 vehicles in Mexico, many of which were shipped to the U.S., including popular models like the Chevrolet Silverado and the GMC Sierra pickup trucks.

The General Motors Ramos Arizpe facility in Ramos Arizpe, Coahuila, Mexico, on Monday, Oct. 7, 2024.

Bloomberg/Getty Images

GM has already started preparing for the potential impact of these tariffs. CEO Mary Barra said that the company is ready to shift some production to U.S. plants to mitigate the impact on its bottom line. However, the uncertainty surrounding the tariffs has made investors uneasy. Jeff Windau, an analyst at Edward Jones, said in a research note that such trade policies could significantly increase vehicle prices, damaging consumer demand and pressuring profits.

Related: Toyota 4Runner Trailhunter is one heck of an off-road rig

Structural challenges in China

Another area of concern for GM is its operations in China. The automaker reported a $4 billion non-cash expense related to the restructuring of its joint venture in China. GM’s focus on its North American business has shielded it from some of the volatility in its international markets, but its performance in China remains a wildcard.

Signage for General Motors Co.’s Chevrolet and Buick at dealerships in Shanghai, China, on Friday, Dec. 6, 2024.

Bloomberg/Getty Images

The Chinese market is crucial for GM’s global strategy, and any prolonged downturn in this region could have serious financial consequences. CEO Barra is hopeful that the restructuring will position GM for better performance in the long run, but the current market realities in China add an extra layer of uncertainty to the company’s outlook.

Related: Rivian’s Volkswagen partnership could reshape the EV market

A delicate balance ahead

Despite these challenges, GM remains optimistic about its future. The company expects modest growth in U.S. vehicle sales for 2025, with overall sales projected to remain at around 16 million vehicles, close to the level seen in 2024. GM also plans to continue expanding its portfolio of both internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles and electric vehicles, emphasizing its diverse product offerings as a hedge against regulatory and market uncertainties.

View the original article to see embedded media.

While the company’s financial guidance for 2025 was strong, the risks tied to tariff uncertainty, the slow pace of EV adoption, and political instability weigh heavily on GM’s outlook. “In our view, the guidance for 2025 leaves no room for errors, and also does not include impact from regulatory changes in the U.S., especially on tariffs and BEV support,” analysts at Bernstein said in a note.

Banking on an uncertain future

So why are investors fleeing GM despite the positive earnings report? The answer lies in the broader sentiment surrounding the automotive industry. Wall Street has grown wary of the sector’s future prospects, especially given the slowdown in EV growth and the regulatory volatility that continues to hang over automakers. Investors seem to be adopting a wait-and-see approach, unsure if GM can weather these challenges without significant disruption to its profitability.

At the same time, GM’s competitors, including Ford and Tesla, are also grappling with similar market and regulatory pressures, leading to a broader sense of unease in the automotive sector. The shift towards electric vehicles remains a high-stakes gamble for all involved, and GM’s ability to execute on its ambitious goals for 2025 will largely determine whether the company can inspire confidence in the long term.

Related: Alfa Romeo prototype from the 1980s revived by Alma Sprint

Final thoughts

General Motors’ earnings report revealed strong financial performance, but the company’s stock price decline underscores the uncertain environment it faces moving forward. While GM’s core North American business remains strong, challenges in the EV market, regulatory changes, and tariff threats cast a long shadow over its future prospects. As investors flee, GM’s management will need to navigate these hurdles with precision to maintain growth and restore confidence in the company.

For now, GM is poised for a potentially strong 2025, but it must prove that it can adapt to the changing automotive landscape while delivering on its ambitious goals. With the right moves, GM could emerge as a leader in both the ICE and EV markets. But, as the market has shown, the road ahead is anything but smooth.

Love reading Autoblog? Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get exclusive articles, insider insights, and the latest updates delivered right to your inbox. Click here to sign up now!

Related: A wave of new EVs are set to hit the U.S. in 2025

Rate this post

Leave a Comment